Teacher’s human rights breached by unproven allegations disclosure

This article by Tom Whitehead has been extracted from the Daily Telegraph here A teacher’s human rights were breached after police included unproven allegations against him in a criminal records check, the High Court ruled yesterday. The PE teacher has not worked for more than two years because the allegation remained on his record even though police [...]

Proposed reforms to Rehabilitation of Offenders Act criticised – Halsbury’s Law Exchange

This article by Lucy Corin appears on the Halsebury Law Exchange website here  Imagine you are a middle-aged man with a young family looking to change career to work as a primary school teacher. When you were 12 you took a chocolate bar from a shop. You learnt a salutary lesson and never repeated this [...]

BBC report that thousands of job applicants will no longer have to face their criminal past being disclosed to employers

The BBC have reported (26th March) that thousands of job applicants will no longer have to face their criminal past being disclosed to employers, under changes announced by the Home Office. Old and minor cautions and convictions will be filtered out of the information revealed in applications for jobs in England and Wales. It follows [...]

Local Safeguarding Children Boards in England given power to request any person or body to supply relevant information

The Children, Schools and Families Act 2010 (Commencement No. 3) Order 2013 has now been enacted. This amends Section 8 of the Act inserts  by inserting Section 14B into the Children Act 2004(b) which  gives Local Safeguarding Children Boards in England the power to request any person or body to supply such information as is specified in [...]

Lord Chief Justice calls for research into effects on children of giving evidence in abuse cases

According to an article in the Guardian by Owen Bowcott, legal affairs correspondent, published on the 20th March, Lord Judge, the Lord Chief Justice calls for research into effects on children of giving evidence in abuse cases. Research should be carried out into the long-term affects on those who give evidence about sexual abuse when they [...]

Couple falsely accused of child abuse win damages from Haringey council

 This item appeared on the Guardian website on the 14th March 2012. Couple falsely accused of child abuse win damages from Haringey council Pair plunged into ‘nightmare’ after anonymous tipoff about treatment of daughter are awarded £2,000 damages in high court Haringey civic centre in Wood Green, north London. The council mishandled its investigation, giving [...]

Parents ‘treated like felons on remand’ by school CRB checks

This extract refers to an article published by the Daily Telegraph (here) on 24th February.  Parents ‘treated like felons on remand’ by school CRB checks Thousands of parents are still being forced to undergo “suspicious and hostile” criminal record checks to volunteer in schools despite Coalition reforms designed to introduce common sense into the child [...]

Manifesto Club provide CRB update

CRB PROBLEMS PERSIST – AND MULTIPLY   Several months after the Protection of Freedoms Act was supposed to have introduced ‘common sense’, problems of over-zealous checks continue:   Privacy problems: The Court of Appeal ruled that minor criminal convictions shouldn’t be returning on CRB checks. Thousands of people can’t get jobs because of old minor convictions, [...]

A breach of human rights: Court of Appeal rules CRB check law must go

This item by Paul Peachey appeared in the Independent on 29th January  A major overhaul of the criminal records regime could be required after three judges ruled that the current system breached human rights. [See judgement here] The Court of Appeal today said that a blanket requirement for some job seekers to supply details of [...]

Using children as a moral shield

Our attention has been drawn to a very thought provoking article by Frank Furedi  in Spiked online here which is well worth reading. It begins …. The new TV campaign by child-protection group the NSPCC, launched in the UK today, urges people to report any concern that they might have about a child. Its exhortation – ‘Don’t [...]

Treating every allegation against Jimmy Savile as a ‘fact’ undermines justice

For a different slant on the Jimmy Saville Affair see the article written by Charles More published in the Daily Telegraph which is reproduced in full below The lead headline on the BBC website yesterday said: “Jimmy Savile scandal: Report reveals extent of abuse”. Well, I have read the whole of the report, and I [...]

We all all want kids to be safe but …

We all  all want kids to be safe, but according to Frank Furedi the plan to create a new database of children who visit A&E units will have the opposite effect. In his latest article which appears on on Spiked Online titled How ‘child protection’ policies harm children  he argues that the plan to create a new database of children [...]

Supreme Court hands down an important judgment which deals with conflicting human rights (Articles 3, 6 and 8) in disputed allegations casee

The Supreme Court has handed down an important judgment in Re A (A Child) [2012] UKSC 60 (12 December 2012) (Lady Hale, with whom Lords Neuberger, Clarke, Wilson and Reed agreed;  appeal against a decision of McFarlane, Thorpe and Hallett LJJ) which deals with conflicting human rights (Articles 8 and 6, as well as an Article 3 claim) Summarising [...]

Manifesto Club: CRB Update

This update is an extract from the Maifesto Club website here  HAVE YOU BEEN VETTED FOR HELPING OUT IN A SCHOOL? Research call-out: Have you been CRB checked for volunteering in schools? We are writing a report about the vetting of school volunteers. If you have any accounts of this, please email. Would CRB checks have stopped Saville?: Radio [...]

Drs advised to report child protection suspicions – even if it is just a hunch

This article appeared on the Daily Telegraph website on the 3rd September The General Medical Council has issued new advice for doctors on child protection urging them to report any fears, even just a hunch, to superiors. Mothers suffering post-natal depression, those using drink or drugs and with violent partners could need to be questionned [...]

Sex offender registration appeals introduced

This items first appeared on the BBC website here on 1st September 2012 Sex offenders in England and Wales can now appeal against staying on the sex offenders register for life – 15 years to the day since it was introduced. Ministers said they would make “minimum possible changes” to comply with a 2010 Supreme [...]

Manifesto Club discover that many people who do not work directly with children are still required to submit to a CRB check

A Manifesto Club report, Vetting Tree Surgeons, finds that nearly a million checks a year are being carried out by local authorities – at a cost of £45 million. Councils CRB checked hundreds of parent volunteers in schools, including parents listening to children read or helping out at the school disco. They also checked tree surgeons, [...]

Child sex abuse convictions rise 60% in six years

The number of people convicted of sex offences on children under 16 in England and Wales has increased by nearly 60% in six years. The BBC said a freedom of information request to the Ministry of Justice found that 1,363 people were convicted in 2005, while in 2010 it was 2,135. The increase is being [...]

Sharon Shoesmith, the former Director of Children’s Services at Haringey Council, has won her appeal

Sharon Shoesmith, the former Director of Children’s Services at Haringey Council, has won an appeal against her dismissal by her former employers and the Secretary of State for Education. Her appeal against Ofsted was dismissed. The Court of Appeal in R (Shoesmith) v Ofsted and others [2011] EWCA Civ 642 has said that the Secretary [...]

Children may be protected from giving evidence in criminal trials

According to an article on the Guardian web site written by  Amelia Hill children may no longer be called to give evidence in the criminal courts except in the “most extraordinary circumstances”, even if that means risking their abusers going free, following a case due to be heard in June. The change could transform the [...]

People working with children and vulnerable adults can now be checked in Jersey for criminal records.

People working with children and vulnerable adults can now be checked in Jersey for criminal records. The checks will be carried out in the island by the Jersey Vetting Bureau. It involves filling out an application form and showing proof of identity. Kevin McKerrell, from the Jersey Vetting Bureau, said: “This marks the start of [...]

The Protections of Freedom Bill

The Protections of Freedom Bill is currently passing through Parliament. Of particular interest to falsely accused carers and teachers will the Committees scrutiny of plans to reform the CRB system and scale back ISA work to common sense levels. Further information on the Bill can be obtained here

Guilty until proven innocent: Volunteers forced to have a million criminal record checks a year

This article by Sarah Harris  first appeared in the Daily Mail (here) on the 14th March 2011 Excessive vetting checks are deterring volunteers and putting vital community services at risk, it was claimed yesterday. Despite Coalition pledges to scale back vetting to ‘commonsense levels’, the Criminal Records Bureau is still checking vast numbers of helpers. [...]

Review on criminal records regime published

Common Sense Approach

The independent review by Sunita Mason on criminal records regime titled  A Common Sense Approach – which FACT contributed to, has been published. In announcing the Review the Home Office said … “The first phase of this two phase review focused on issues concerned with the extent and demands of pre-employment vetting systems and the [...]

Minister proposes common sense approach to public protection

The following is an extract from a media release was issued by the Home Office Media Centre on the 11th February 2011 (here) Millions of people will be protected from unwarranted state intrusion in their private lives, the Home Secretary has outlined today. An array of reforms in the Protection of Freedoms Bill will put [...]